New Order vs. Pet Shop Boys

At some point, someone’s probably asked, “Who’s your favorite band?” For some, the response might be immediate; but for any serious music aficionado, I suspect the decision might require some deliberation.

I’ve narrowed mine down to two highly respected musical acts: New Order and Pet Shop Boys. For a long time, the Mancunian legends claimed the top spot; but after New Order fell apart, the Boys gained traction. I tend to waver between them based on mood and what each act is currently doing.

It’s not apples to apples comparing the two, but here are a few assets that each group respectively has in its favor:

New Order

  • Prior history as Joy Division
  • Association with Factory Records
  • They built The Hacienda
  • “Blue Monday”
  • Production work for other artists
  • Entertaining side projects (Electronic, Revenge, The Other Two, Monaco, Bad Lieutenant)
  • Their ‘don’t give a shit’ attitude
  • Designer: Peter Saville

Pet Shop Boys

  • Remarkably consistent quality of song writing and releases
  • B-sides better than most bands’ A-sides
  • Work with other artists: collaborations, songwriting, production, and remixes
  • Innovative concert performances
  • Creative endeavors in film, theatre, and dance
  • Sharp image and style
  • Highly attentive to fans (‘Petheads’)
  • Designer: Mark Farrow

So, who do like better? Please cast your vote.

And need I ask… who’s your favorite musical artist?

Posted on June 12, 2012, in New Order, Pet Shop Boys, SHELF. Bookmark the permalink. 16 Comments.

  1. A fan of New Order, but a bigger fan of PSB.
    Look at the work they did for Liza, Dusty, Eighth Wonder, Kylie and Tina…fabulous!

  2. •B-sides better than most bands’ A-sides, I agree !
    Im a hugh PSB b-side FREAK ! Love the work on their B-sides better than on the A sides.

    I saw their last concert and the Box’s on their heads were really annoying though. LOL

    • It is a conscious effort on PSB’s part to write and record decent B-sides. They always felt that consumers have been shortchanged in the singles department during the 7″ and 12″ era, and they deserve an equally brilliant B-side for the $$$ they pay.

  3. •Entertaining side projects (Electronic, Revenge, The Other Two, Monaco, Bad Lieutenant)
    New Order side projects RULE!

    now that would be a great POST Shelf !
    Electronic – Dissapointed

  4. My favourite? David Bowie. But PSB and NO come a close joint second.

  5. PSB the ‘boys from London’ ? London ? No, the north-east and Blackpool !

    • Right you are – should have known that after watching “A Life In Pop.” I was thinking of where Neil and Chris first met (Chelsea). My humblest apologies – I have removed the erroneous reference. Thanks Art.

      • yeah, this can’t be just a simple coincedence. i didn’t know that chelsea was the place they first met. but chelsea is my favourite football team for a long time. and PSB, i love them so much since i was a kid.

        i voted they’re both great, cuz that’s what it is. it’s just that i love PSB a tad more. it was a “deserted island question” – sort of entartaining ourselves – if you’re allowed to take 10 cds, 5 cds, 3 cds and at last, only 1 cds. that’s how i narrowed the case – that one album for me was “popart” by PSB. i know it’s a double-disc compilation, but still that wasn’t the matter))
        and i wasn’t thinking much, i was feeling)))

        you redlined these assets of both – thanks for that))

        • You must have been ecstatic this year with Chelsea winning the FA Cup AND the UEFA Champions League. I was surprised to read how much team owner Roman Abramovich paid for those victories – over two billion U.S. dollars! That’s just insane spending for player acquisition and salaries.

          I’m so glad you mentioned the Desert Island Discs concept – I think the BBC started that years ago. I compiled a list 25 years ago that was published in the old Tower Records Pulse magazine – I’ll have to dig that out and post it on the site, along with an updated selection. I think “PopArt” will be on my new list, as well.

  6. They are both good but my all time fav band is Depeche Mode. followed by Joy Division/New Order, The Cure and The Smiths.

  7. they’re both great. if i had to choose, i guess i’d go with new order because they came from joy division and j.d. is my favorite band. and my favorite electronic music artist would be the orb.

What's On Your Mind?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: